Thank you to Dr. Ayşe Yavuz, a communications volunteer for COCAG Working Group 3, for writing this reflective post following Jarkko Immonen’s webinar on Cruel Optimism and Career Guidance. Dr. Ayşe Yavuz holds a PhD in Educational Sciences from Aydın Adnan Menderes University, Türkiye, and has a background in Psychological Counseling and Guidance.
What if hope does not always help us move forward? What if, sometimes, it becomes part of how we exploit ourselves?
This was one of the questions I took away from Jarkko Immonen’s COCAG webinar, Cruel Optimism and Career Guidance: (Beyond) the Case of Non-EU Students in Finland. Drawing on Berlant’s (2011) idea of cruel optimism, the webinar explored how our attachment to ideas of “the good life” can become harmful when the very things we hope will help us flourish begin to work against us. For non-EU students in Finland, this creates a particular tension between the promises attached to international education, work and belonging and the structural barriers they may face (Immonen, 2024).
But this tension is not limited to international students. Think about some familiar messages around careers: find meaningful work, develop yourself, stay hopeful, be resilient, keep adapting. There is nothing inherently wrong with these ideas. The problem begins when they become the main response to conditions that individuals cannot change on their own.
This is something I have been thinking about in my own work on psychological capital. Hope, optimism, resilience and self-efficacy can genuinely help people. But when these qualities become closely tied to performance and continuous self-development, they can also shift attention away from the conditions people are trying to navigate (Yavuz & Çengel Schoville, 2026). The promise of meaningful work raises a similar question. Meaning at work cannot simply be created by the individual; it also depends on relational and social conditions that make meaningful work possible (Tommasi et al., 2025).
Seen this way, cruel optimism is not about judging our hopes as unrealistic. It is about what happens through our attachment to them. If work is not fulfilling, work on yourself. If opportunities are limited, become more employable. If uncertainty is exhausting, become more resilient. The conditions may remain the same, while the individual is expected to keep changing.
This focus on the self matters. We are increasingly encouraged to manage, improve and realise ourselves (Rose, 1999). When this becomes an ongoing demand, pressure does not always need to come from someone else. We can push ourselves because it feels like freedom, ambition or self-fulfilment. This is where Han’s (2021) idea of self-exploitation helps us see the other side of the promise. We may become responsible for both setting the demands and trying to meet them, while failure becomes something we experience as our own. For Han, self-exploitation can work precisely because it is experienced through a sense of freedom rather than external force.
Jarkko’s presentation also made me reflect on my own twelve months at the University of Helsinki as a PhD researcher from Türkiye. Although my position was different from that of the students in his research, I recognised the expectations he described around studying and building a future in Finland. I was not entirely free from them either. At the same time, I tend to keep my expectations low, even when I am hopeful about something. The webinar made me wonder whether this might also be a form of self-protection: can keeping our expectations modest protect us from the disappointment that may come with the promises we invest in? If so, I may be quite good at this.
I also listened to the webinar as someone with a background in school counselling. Hope, resilience and self-belief can be important resources, and I would not argue otherwise. But this discussion made me think more carefully about what we are asking these qualities to do. Are they helping people expand their possibilities, or helping them endure conditions that also need to change?
Jarkko suggested that career guidance can be a space where the invisible is made visible and the inaudible heard. Perhaps cruel optimism gives us a useful way to start that conversation.
So, I would like to pass the question on to you: when does supporting hope, resilience and adaptation help people move towards the lives they want, and when might it simply help them adjust to conditions that should themselves be questioned?
References
Berlant, L. (2011). Cruel Optimism. Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1215/9780822394716
Han, B.-C. (2021). ‘I am sorry, but these are the facts’ (D. Steuer, Trans.). In Capitalism and the death drive. Polity.
Immonen, J. (2024). Julman optimistinen mallitarina kotimaisten yliopistojen kansainvälisessä hakijamarkkinoinnissa [A cruelly optimistic model story in Finnish universities’ international student marketing]. Kasvatus [The Finnish Journal of Education], 55(3), 303–318. https://doi.org/10.33348/kvt.145790
Rose, N. (1999). Governing the soul: The shaping of the private self (2nd edn). Free Association Books.
Tommasi, F., Degen, J. L., & Bal, P. M. (2025). “Loving your work (unfortunately, the privilege of a few)”: Primo Levi and what makes life and work meaningful. Human Arenas. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42087-025-00516-8
Yavuz, A., & Çengel Schoville, M. (2026). Rethinking psychological capital: A Bourdieusian critique of neoliberal subjectivity. Human Arenas. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42087-026-00557-7
